Chapter 11 · Probability

Comparing Probabilities and Making Predictions

Compare probabilities to decide which event is more likely, then use a probability to predict about how often an event should happen over many trials.

18 min read

You want a red marble, and you may draw from either of two bags. Which bag gives you the better chance? Now imagine spinning a spinner 200200 times. About how many spins should land on red? Probability answers both questions.

A probability is a number from 00 to 11 that tells you how likely an event is. An event is a result, or a group of results, that you are interested in, such as drawing a red marble. The closer the probability is to 11, the more likely the event. The closer it is to 00, the less likely the event. A probability near 12\frac{1}{2} means the event is neither likely nor unlikely.

You already know how to find one. An outcome is one single possible result, and the favourable outcomes are the ones that make the event happen. When all the outcomes are equally likely (each has the same chance), the probability of the event, written P(event)P(\text{event}), is the number of favourable outcomes divided by the total number of outcomes. A probability found by reasoning like this, without running an experiment, is a theoretical probability.

To decide which of two events is more likely, compare their probabilities. The event with the greater probability is more likely. If the probabilities are equal, the events are equally likely.

Try it with a number cube. Its faces show 11, 22, 33, 44, 55 and 66, and each face is equally likely to land on top. Three of the six faces are even (22, 44, 66), so P(even)=36P(\text{even}) = \frac{3}{6}. Two of the six faces are greater than 44 (55, 66), so P(greater than 4)=26P(\text{greater than } 4) = \frac{2}{6}. Both fractions count sixths, and 36>26\frac{3}{6} > \frac{2}{6}, so rolling an even number is more likely.

Often the denominators differ. Then the two fractions count parts of different sizes, and you cannot judge by the numerators alone. First write both probabilities in the same form:

  • fractions with a common denominator (the same bottom number), or
  • decimals or percentages. If you round, keep enough digits to tell the numbers apart.

An equal fraction, decimal or percentage shows the same value in a new form, so the comparison stays fair.

Worked example

Red from two different bags

Bag A holds 1212 marbles: 55 red and 77 blue. Bag B holds 2020 marbles: 88 red and 1212 blue. In each bag the marbles are the same size and well mixed. You draw one marble from one bag without looking. From which bag is a red marble more likely?

  1. Write the probability of red for each bag. In each bag every marble is equally likely to be drawn, so you can use the number of red marbles over the total number of marbles.

    P(red from A)=512,P(red from B)=820P(\text{red from A}) = \frac{5}{12}, \quad P(\text{red from B}) = \frac{8}{20}
  2. The denominators 12 and 20 are different, so choose a common denominator. The number 60 works because it is a multiple of both 12 and 20.

    12×5=60,20×3=6012 \times 5 = 60, \quad 20 \times 3 = 60
  3. Rewrite each fraction with the denominator 60. Multiplying the numerator and the denominator by the same non-zero number is the same as multiplying by 1, so the value does not change.

    512=5×512×5=2560,820=8×320×3=2460\frac{5}{12} = \frac{5 \times 5}{12 \times 5} = \frac{25}{60}, \quad \frac{8}{20} = \frac{8 \times 3}{20 \times 3} = \frac{24}{60}
  4. Compare the numerators. Both fractions now count sixtieths, so the greater numerator shows the greater probability.

    2560>2460\frac{25}{60} > \frac{24}{60}
  5. Check with decimals, because a second form should give the same order. Divide each numerator by its denominator and keep three decimal places.

    5÷12≈0.417,8÷20=0.400,0.417>0.4005 \div 12 \approx 0.417, \quad 8 \div 20 = 0.400, \quad 0.417 > 0.400

Answer

A red marble is more likely from Bag A, because 512\frac{5}{12} is greater than 820\frac{8}{20}. This is true even though Bag B holds more red marbles.

Now use probability to look ahead. A trial is one run of a chance activity, such as one spin or one draw. Suppose you repeat the same activity for many trials and count how often an event happens. The relative frequency of the event is the number of times it happened divided by the number of trials. If an event happens 1818 times in 5050 trials, its relative frequency is 1850\frac{18}{50}.

Here is the link that makes prediction possible. Over many trials, the relative frequency tends to be close to the theoretical probability. An event with probability 14\frac{1}{4} tends to happen in about one quarter of a long run of trials.

So you can predict before you start. In 400400 trials, about one quarter should give the event: 14×400=100\frac{1}{4} \times 400 = 100. This predicted number is called the expected count.

An expected count is an estimate, not a guarantee. After only a few trials, the relative frequency can be far from the probability, so trust the link only over many trials.

Key concept

One number, two jobs: compare and predict

A probability measures how likely an event is, so you can use it in two ways.

Compare: write the probabilities in the same form. The event with the greater probability is more likely.

Predict: multiply the probability by the number of trials to get the expected count. Each trial must have the same probability.

Keep the conditions with the rules. Favourable outcomes over total outcomes is a probability only when the outcomes are equally likely. Every probability is from 00 to 11, so an expected count is from 00 to the number of trials. An expected count is an estimate for many trials, not a guarantee.

expected count=P(event)×number of trials\text{expected count} = P(\text{event}) \times \text{number of trials}

Worked example

Predicting red spins

A spinner has 88 sections of equal size: 33 red, 22 blue, 22 green and 11 yellow. The arrow is equally likely to stop in each section. You spin it 200200 times. About how many spins should you expect to land on red?

  1. Find the theoretical probability of red on one spin. The 8 equal sections are the equally likely outcomes, and 3 of them are red. The 4 colours are not equally likely, so 1 out of 4 would be wrong.

    P(red)=38P(\text{red}) = \frac{3}{8}
  2. Let x be the expected number of red spins out of 200. Over many spins, the fraction of spins that land on red should be close to the probability of red, so set the two fractions equal to make the prediction.

    x200=38\frac{x}{200} = \frac{3}{8}
  3. Multiply both sides by 200. Multiplying both sides of an equation by the same number keeps the two sides equal, and it leaves x alone on the left.

    x=38×200=6008=75x = \frac{3}{8} \times 200 = \frac{600}{8} = 75
  4. Check by simplifying the predicted fraction of red spins. Dividing the numerator and the denominator by the same non-zero number, here 25, does not change the value, and you get the probability of red back.

    75200=75÷25200÷25=38\frac{75}{200} = \frac{75 \div 25}{200 \div 25} = \frac{3}{8}

Answer

You should expect about 7575 of the 200200 spins to land on red. This is an estimate: the real count will probably be close to 7575, but it does not have to equal 7575.

The spinner with 8 equal sections: every colour over 200 spins
ColourEqual sectionsProbability on one spinExpected count in 200 spins
Red
33
38\frac{3}{8}
38×200=75\frac{3}{8} \times 200 = 75
Blue
22
28\frac{2}{8}
28×200=50\frac{2}{8} \times 200 = 50
Green
22
28\frac{2}{8}
28×200=50\frac{2}{8} \times 200 = 50
Yellow
11
18\frac{1}{8}
18×200=25\frac{1}{8} \times 200 = 25
Total
88
88=1\frac{8}{8} = 1
200200

The table uses both skills at once.

Compare. Red has the greatest probability, 38\frac{3}{8}, so red is the most likely colour. Blue and green both have 28\frac{2}{8}, so they are equally likely. Yellow has the least, 18\frac{1}{8}, so it is the least likely.

Predict. The expected counts follow the same order: 7575, then 5050 and 5050, then 2525. You multiply every probability by the same positive number of spins, so a greater probability gives a greater expected count.

Check. Every probability in the table is from 00 to 11. Each spin lands on exactly one colour, so the probabilities of all the colours add to 11. That is why the expected counts add to the number of spins: 75+50+50+25=20075 + 50 + 50 + 25 = 200. If your totals do not match, look for a slip in the arithmetic.

Worked example

Compare, then predict, with a complement

A bag holds 2020 tiles of the same size: 99 green, 66 white and 55 black. Each time, you mix the tiles, draw one without looking, record its colour and put it back. You do this 300300 times. On one draw, which is more likely: a green tile or a tile that is not green? About how many of each should you expect in 300300 draws?

  1. Find the probability of green on one draw. All 20 tiles are equally likely to be drawn, and 9 of them are green.

    P(green)=920P(\text{green}) = \frac{9}{20}
  2. Find the probability of not green. An event and its complement (the event not happening) have probabilities that add to 1, so subtract from 1. This matches the 6 white and 5 black tiles, which make 11 of the 20.

    P(not green)=1−920=2020−920=1120P(\text{not green}) = 1 - \frac{9}{20} = \frac{20}{20} - \frac{9}{20} = \frac{11}{20}
  3. Compare. The denominators are the same, so the greater numerator shows the more likely event.

    1120>920\frac{11}{20} > \frac{9}{20}
  4. Predict the count for not green. The tile goes back after every draw, so each of the 300 draws has the same 20 tiles and the same probability. That lets you multiply.

    1120×300=330020=165\frac{11}{20} \times 300 = \frac{3300}{20} = 165
  5. Predict the count for green in the same way, because the probability of green is also the same on every draw.

    920×300=270020=135\frac{9}{20} \times 300 = \frac{2700}{20} = 135
  6. Check. Every draw is either green or not green, so the two expected counts must add to the number of draws.

    165+135=300165 + 135 = 300

Answer

On each draw, a tile that is not green is more likely than a green tile. In 300300 draws you should expect about 165165 tiles that are not green and about 135135 green tiles. These are estimates, not guarantees.

Takeaway. A probability is one number that does two jobs. To compare events, write their probabilities in the same form: the greater probability marks the more likely event, whatever the raw counts say. To predict, multiply the probability by the number of trials to get the expected count.

Keep the conditions with the rules. Favourable over total needs equally likely outcomes. A prediction needs the same probability on every trial, and it is an estimate to trust only over many trials, never a guarantee.